Comparing the Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingle Roofs: Which is Better?

When it comes to making decisions about your home and its vital components, things can get intimidating. You want something that will last, something that looks good, and of course, something that won’t break the bank. One of the crucial decisions to make is that of your roof: metal roofing or shingle roofing?

Metal roofing has certainly become more popular in recent years, and it is easy to see why. But what pros and cons come with metal roofing? What are the advantages and disadvantages of shingle roofing? And just as importantly, how will they impact your wallet?

In this blog post, we will dive into the world of metal vs shingle roofs and answer all these questions. Fasten your seatbelts, as we compare cost, durability, and aesthetic appeal, to help you make the best decision for your home. Let’s get to it!

Generally, metal roofs tend to cost more than a traditional shingle roof but they usually last much longer. The cost difference also varies depending on your location and the types of materials used.

Cost Comparison: Metal Roof vs Shingle

When considering the cost comparison of metal roofs versus shingle roofs, one of the main advantages of a shingle roof is that it tends to be much more affordable right out of the gate. Asphalt and composite shingles are far less expensive than their metal counterparts when installed for the first time, though if you plan on replacing an older roof then this might not be as big of a factor. However, those initial savings need to be weighed against the fact that metal roofs can last 50-60 years whereas the lifespan of a shingle roof averages around 12-20 years depending on several factors.

Despite the lower upfront cost associated with shingles, over the long term a metal roof is often the most cost effective option due to its significantly longer life span. On average, adding a new metal roof will require a larger investment but that investment pays off in terms of reduced repair and replacement costs over time. Moreover, depending on local building codes and your area’s climate there may be tax credits or other incentives available which could offset some of the higher up front cost of metals.

Due to the longevity associated with these materials and the higher initial investment usually necessary for them, it really comes down to budget and whether you’re willing to pay more right now in exchange for fewer repairs and/or replacements later on. To sum up, while shingle roofs are typically cheaper in terms of upfront installation costs they still tend to be more expensive when considered over their entire life span — making metal roofs an attractive option from an economic standpoint.

Finally, we must begin to weigh both sides of this argument by exploring further in our next section: Advantages & Disadvantages of Metal Roofs.

  • On average, metal roofing costs 20-40% more than traditional asphalt shingle roofs, with an average cost of $12,000-$14,000 for a medium-sized 1,500 square foot roof.
  • Metal roofing has been found to last two to three times longer than asphalt shingle roofing due to its durability and ability to withstand harsh weather conditions.
  • On average, metal roofs can last 40-70 years while traditional asphalt shingle roofs may need replacement after 15-30 years.

Top Points to Remember

Metal roofs can be more expensive to install initially than shingle roofs, but they typically last up to five times longer. This means that they are often more cost-effective in the long term. Depending on local building codes, there may also be deductions available which could help to reduce the initial installation costs of metal roofs. In terms of budget and longevity, it is important to compare both options in order to make an informed decision.

Advantages & Disadvantages of Metal Roofs

Metal roofs offer a variety of advantages which can make them an attractive option for many homeowners. Metal is incredibly lightweight and highly fire and wind resistant, making it an excellent choice for those living in areas with extreme weather conditions. Metal requires minimal maintenance after installation and may last between 25 to 50 years with adequate care—making it relatively cost effective over the long-term. Installation costs for metal roofs can be higher than for other traditional roofing materials, making an up-front investment more substantial. However, the protection from weather and longevity of the material may prove to be a wise choice in the end.

Another advantage of metal roofs is energy efficiency. Due to the reflective material used in most metal products, they can help minimize cooling costs in the summer because they reflect heat away. This effect also increases indoor air quality as temperatures indoors are kept lower during warmer months.

While there are certainly some benefits to installing a metal roof, there are also some potential drawbacks that should be considered. Noise can be an issue; depending on whether you have a standing seam or near-by high winds, you could experience louder noises than with shingle roofing materials. Additionally, certain types of metal roofing can dent slightly when exposed to debris such as hail or heavy branches; this damage is normally cosmetic and doesn’t affect the integrity of the roof system but should still be taken into consideration upon installation.

In conclusion, metal roofs provide homeowners with many advantages including excellent weather resistance, longer life spans and potential cooling cost savings. While noise levels and possible dents should also be factored into decision making process prior to installation, overall metal roofing may prove to be a worthwhile investment. Moving forward, let’s consider another aspect of comparing roofs: durability and longevity.

Durability and Longevity

When talking about durability and longevity, metal roofing definitely stands out from asphalt shingles. Quality metal roofing is often warranted for a lifetime, which means that it can last for decades without needing to be replaced. With proper installation, it can even still hold up in extreme temperatures and against weather damage. Asphalt shingles are only typically guaranteed for around 20 years, but might need replacing sooner due to fading from exposure or fracturing from heavy winds. Additionally, selecting higher quality asphalt shingles with thicker layers of granules can help protect against these types of issues.

Ultimately, both metal roofs and shingle roofs can have their advantages and disadvantages when considering durability and longevity. Metal roofs are generally more durable, however depending on the thickness of the shingle utilized, asphalt roof may also be effective in protecting your home over the long-term if maintained properly.

To conclude this section on durability and longevity, it is important to consider the quality of materials being used when deciding between metal roofs and asphalt shingles. This will be discussed in more detail in the next section.

Quality of Materials

When it comes to the quality of materials for roofs, there is a fair comparison between metal roofing and shingle roofing. Both materials offer different levels of protection from the elements, safety, insulation and longevity.

Metal Roofing: Metal roofs are made from recycled materials and are considered to be much more durable than asphalt shingle roofs. The material used for metal roofs is usually galvanized or aluminum steel coated with protective sealant or primer. A metal roof will last for many decades, require minimal maintenance and can withstand extreme weather conditions better than shingle roofing. In addition, metal roofs are able to reflect more solar energy than asphalt shingle roofs, which can make them more energy efficient. The downside is that a metal roof is more expensive upfront than an asphalt shingle roof, and it also requires a professional installation which adds to the cost.

Shingle Roofs: Shingle roofs are made from a variety of materials including asphalt, wood and clay tiles. Asphalt shingles are the most common option because they are relatively inexpensive and easy to install. However, they do lack durability when compared to metal roofing and need to be replaced every 10-15 years depending on the climate in which they were installed. Wood shakes may last slightly longer but also require regular maintenance such as staining in order to extend their lifespan. Clay tiles often boast an extensive life expectancy but tend to be very expensive and fragile.

Overall, both options offer different levels of quality based on the individual budget and preferences of homeowners. Metal roofing offers greater longevity, although it often costs significantly more than installing a shingle roof. Depending on the environment in which a person lives, either one could provide adequate shelter from the elements.

The next section will discuss the impact of these two types of rooftops on the environment.

Impact on the Environment

When it comes to the impact on the environment, metal roofs and asphalt shingle roofs have very different effects. Metal roofs are often made with recycled material such as aluminum and steel, but the installation process can be quite energy-intensive due to the large amounts of tools and resources needed. On the other hand, asphalt shingles are not made with recyclable materials since they contain plastic and fiberglass. Additionally, the manufacturing process of asphalt shingles produces emissions of volatile organic compounds like benzene and formaldehyde that release into the air, leading to pollution of local ecosystems.

The environmental performance goes beyond just production, however. Asphalt shingles need to be replaced more frequently than metal roofing systems, so more waste is created throughout their life-cycle. Regularly replacing asphalt shingles requires a truck for pick-up and disposal, which leads to fuel emissions from the truck itself in addition to those generated from production. In comparison, metal roofs typically last longer than their asphalt counterparts and generate less waste throughout its life-cycle due to its extended durability. Furthermore, since metal roofs are lightweight and noncombustible they also reduce fire risk in forested settings.

Overall, both metal roofing systems and asphalt shingles can have an impact on the environment depending on their manufacturing processes, transport needs, how often they are replaced, and other factors. To further examine the advantages and disadvantages between these two roofing options let’s now look at what each option has to offer in terms of “Advantages & Disadvantages of Shingles”.

Advantages & Disadvantages of Shingles

Shingles are a common roofing material, providing an economical and aesthetically pleasing exterior finish to many homes. Shingles come in many different types and styles, including asphalt shingles. Asphalt shingles have been a popular choice among homeowners for several reasons, such as their affordability and relatively easy installation.

Advantages of Shingles

The main advantages of asphalt shingles include affordability, ease of installation and availability. Depending on the quality chosen for your home, asphalt shingles can cost up to 40% less than metal roofs. Additionally, the installation is much faster and easier than with other roof materials due to their lightweight composition. Asphalt shingles are also widely available through most retailers that provide roofing supplies or products.

Disadvantages of Shingles

As with any roofing material, there are some drawbacks to using asphalt shingles. The life expectancy of an asphalt shingle roof is usually be considerably shorter than a metal roof – usually only lasting 10-20 years vs 30-50+ years for a metal roof. Depending on the area where you live, the possibility of strong storms or hail may cause premature deterioration or damage to an asphalt shingle roof, necessitating costly repairs sooner rather than later in its lifespan. As well, since asphalt shingles are made from petroleum products, they are sensitive to ultraviolet light exposure and may need more frequent maintenance over time in order to ensure longevity.

Overall, while there are both advantages and disadvantages of using asphalt shingles in comparison to metal roofs for residential housing, ultimately it is up to the home owner to decide what type ofmaterial best suits their budget and level of desired maintenance. It should be noted that both types of roofs require regular maintenance over time in order to keep them functioning correctly and looking their best.

Now that we’ve discussed the pros and cons of both metal roofs and shingle roofs, let’s explore what each option costs when it comes to installation and maintenance costs in our next section.

Installation Cost & Maintenance

To decide which roofing option is better, it’s important to consider installation costs and maintenance requirements. Metal roofs generally cost more than shingle roofs to install, with a national average of $11.50 per square foot for metal and $7.00 for asphalt. The type of metal used in the roof will also affect the price, with steel costing on average $5-$12 per square foot, while aluminum costs between $8-$10 per square foot. However, metal roofing can last up to 50 years or longer depending on the material, while an asphalt roof may have to be replaced every fifteen to twenty years.

Maintenance costs should also be taken into account prior to choosing a roof type as metal roofs require significantly less maintenance than a shingled roof. While metal roofs are considered much more durable than asphalt shingles, they can still corrode if exposed to salt air or humidity over time. To protect the metal from corrosion, it may need to be treated regularly by applying a coating or sealant and checked for signs of wear or damage. Asphalt shingle roofs require annual inspections and maintenance such as cleaning debris out of gutters and repairing any damaged shingles or torn flashing.

Overall, when taking installation cost and maintenance into consideration, metal roofs may be more expensive upfront but save money in repairs and replacements further down the line. Thus, it is important for homeowners considering both options to think about long-term investment rather than short-term savings. The following section will discuss long-term considerations when comparing the cost of metal roofs vs shingle roofs.

Long-Term Considerations

When considering roofing materials, it’s essential to take a long-term view. While the upfront cost of shingle roofs may be more attractive than metal roofs, this isn’t necessarily an indication of better value in the long run. Since metal roofing is expected to last anywhere from 30 – 50 years with proper maintenance and installation, the lower initial investment with shingle roofs may end up costing homeowners more due to repeated replacements over time. Metal roofing has been known to increase home value and cut down on energy bills due to its higher reflectivity. Conversely, shingle roofs tend to require frequent replacement which could mean more costly repairs overall.

Additionally, many homeowners overlook the fact that local building codes require certain materials based on location and climate conditions. Therefore, it’s important for any homeowner making this decision to understand their local code and possibly even consult a professional contractor to make sure they are selecting the right material for their specific building needs.

The next section of this article will discuss factors that impact cost when comparing metal and shingle roofs.

Factors That Impact Cost

Cost is one of the biggest factors when it comes to deciding between a metal roof and a shingle roof. While the cost of a metal roof will be higher upfront, there are other factors that can impact the final cost over time. In fact, the total cost of ownership for either roof type could vary significantly.

Installation costs are one of the most basic factors to consider when looking at cost. Metal roofs generally require more specialized labor due to their heavier weight, custom panels and flashing needs. Shingle roofs on the other hand can be installed faster with fewer tools, which can lead to lower installation costs.

The lifespan of each roof type also impacts its total cost over time. While metal roofs last longer than shingles, they also require more investment up-front because they cost more. On the other hand, shingle roofs are cheaper initially, but they tend to need replacing every 15 years or so. Therefore, if you plan to stay in your home for an extended period of time, investing in a metal roof may turn out to be more cost effective in the long run.

Energy savings can be another important factor in terms of overall cost. Metal roofs have been shown to be more energy efficient than asphalt shingles due to their reflective material and ability to keep homes cooler in summer months. Lower energy bills mean better insulation against extreme temperatures and thus lower heating and cooling costs.

Finally, maintenance costs must also be taken into consideration. Metal roofs require less maintenance than shingle roofs and can often last longer without repairs or replacement because they don’t suffer from damage caused by mold or moss buildup or exposure to wind or hail. On the other hand, shingle roofs require periodic maintenance and repair work since they are not as durable as metal roofs and can suffer damage more easily due to weather exposure or UV rays.

In conclusion, there are several factors that can impact the total cost associated with having either a metal roof or a shingle roof installed on a home. Installation costs, lifespan, energy efficiency and ongoing maintenance should all be taken into account when trying to determine which option is better suited to your budget and lifestyle. The next section will cover our conclusion about which roof type is best from a cost perspective.


Ultimately, when comparing the cost of metal roof vs shingle roof the decision will depend on the needs and budget of the homeowner. Both come with their advantages and disadvantages, and neither is necessarily the ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ choice.

Metal roofs can often be a more expensive roofing option at the outset, but they last up to four times as long as shingle roofs and can also improve energy efficiency. This could mean long-term savings for homeowners who choose a metal roof.

On the other hand, shingle roofs are usually the most cost-effective option in terms of initial installation costs. They can also be easier to maintain over time than metal roofs due to needing fewer repairs. However, this does mean that shingle roofs must be replaced more often and will not provide nearly as much energy savings as metal roofs.

When deciding between a metal roof vs shingle roof, it is important to consider all factors involved including upfront and long-term costs, energy efficiency, maintenance needs, and aesthetic appeal. By weighing these factors against one another, homeowners can make an educated decision about what type of roof best meets their specific needs while staying within their budget.

Frequently Asked Questions and Explanations

How long can I expect each roof to last before needing a replacement?

Generally speaking, a metal roof is expected to last 50-75 years before needing a replacement, while a shingle roof will only last around 15-30 years. This is because a metal roof is made of heavy-duty materials that are built to withstand extreme weather conditions and protect the underlying structure of your home. The shingle roof is composed of lighter materials and can be more susceptible to weather damage over time. Additionally, metal roofs do not require as much maintenance as shingle roofs and can often last longer without needing repair or replacement. Ultimately, the cost difference between metal and shingle roofs typically comes with a longer lifespan of the former option which is something to consider when deciding between the two.

What are the benefits and drawbacks of each roofing material?

The benefits and drawbacks of metal roof vs shingle roof depend largely on the intended usage, budget, and preference.

Metal roofs are known to be more durable than shingles and can last significantly longer—up to 50 years—with proper maintenance. They’re highly resistant to fire and harsh weather conditions, plus they don’t deteriorate like asphalt shingles do. Metal roofs are also lightweight, come in a wide range of styles, and offer superior energy efficiency since they allow for a tighter seal with less heat loss. The drawbacks of metal roofing include the fact that it may be noisy when it rains or hails and tends to be more expensive than shingles.

On the other hand, shingle roofs are simpler to install due to their lighter weight and can cost much less than metal roofs. They do require more maintenance in order to keep them from deteriorating over time, but when properly cared for, can last 20-25 years before needing to be replaced. One challenge with shingle roofs is that unless you use rubber shingles, there can be a risk of fire caused by the buildup of material underneath them during hot months. That said, this risk is small compared to the overall benefits of installing a shingle roof.

Overall, both metal and shingle roofs have their own unique pros and cons depending on the specific situation. It is best to consider your budget and preferences as well as climate conditions when trying to determine which material is best for your roofing needs.

What factors can influence the cost of a metal roof or shingle roof?

The cost of both metal roof and shingle roof installations can be influenced by a variety of factors, including the roof’s size and complexity, materials used, labor costs and any special features such as vents and insulation.

For metal roofs the cost is often dictated by the type of material chosen. For example, aluminum is typically the most affordable option while copper is usually the most expensive. The complexity of installation can play a factor in cost as well; more complicated designs can lead to higher labor fees as extra time and equipment may be required to complete the job.

For shingle roofs, cost is often determined by the type of material chosen such as asphalt or wood shingles. The grade or quality of materials used also influences cost—higher grades typically cost more than lower grades but can last longer. Labor costs, removal fees and other associated costs will also affect price. Cost may increase if additional features like vents are required to prevent an excessive build up of heat in the attic. The local climate may also play a role in cost; colder climates may require an increased number of layers in order to trap heat in the home, which could affect overall price.






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *